Silverfast does not include a scanner driver and requires the minolta scanner driver which is not compatible with windows 10 to be installed. I use the manufacturers software for general scanning and vuescan for the serious stuff even though the output i want from vuescan is simpler in terms of scanning manipulations and the output does initially look horrible. Even for a simple question about using the software not a bug, not a complaint, just a legitimate question, they open a ticket with the support hotline. One very last thing, i forgot to write one advantage that silverfast definitely has over vuescan. I dont know silverfast, i have tons of film which i usually scan with the canon fs4000us and. Vuescan scanner software for macos catalina, windows 10. Some scanner manufacturers bundle their hardware with silverfast. In august last year my winxp pc gave out and i replaced it knowing that my scanner would now be obsolete. It does not matter which software you use, vuescan, epson scan or silverfast, none of them are capable of electronic focus control because there is no focusing adjustment built into the scanner for either of the two lenses. Vs also has a direct to raw, aka raw from the scanner ccd. The crop tool is nice and easy to use, and allows you to tilt the frame slightly if necessary. Given the cost of silverfast and i use two scanners, the 9000 and the v ed coolscans so it would be. I just tried the trial of silverfast that came with my epson 4870 and its more interesting than the last time i tried it. There upgrade prices are ridiculous especially when you consider the initial price of the software.
I had to start somewhere, so i gave vuescan a go and used it for many months. I compared both images with the compare button using faststone image viewer 5. The scanner provides a very good image quality when scanning documents and is very fast. Your choice of software has a lot to do with how efficient and how. The image is more rich in color and also abit more details. After some 20 years, im quite accustomed to its idiosyncrasies. Yea, the mutiexposure feature now in silverfast really interested me if it could increase the dynamic range of my. What do you like about vuescan over the native scanning software that came with your scanner. Scanner software silverfast for windows 10 and macos. That said its also super clunky and the workflow is a little bizzarre.
Here my testing shows the silverfast software produced better results than the epson software but the difference between silverfast and vuescan is marginal. In this course, photographer and scanning expert taz tally describes how to use the lasersoft imaging silverfast software to scan photos, line art, film negatives, and other printed documents, while getting the highest quality scans possible from your scanner. With the professional scan software silverfast ai studio the canon canoscan 9000f mark ii also achieves a very good image quality when scanning slides and negatives, especially. I use vuescan it takes some time to get up to speed with it, and the user interface can be a bit intimidating, but it supports nearly every scanner there is, and can deliver very consistent good results. In practice, i find silverfast more consistently accurate than vuescan. One of the features of vuescan is that it works on so many scanners and platforms,the silverfast software is designed to work only with the scanner it was made for i have heard. I stepped over to vuescan and this proved to be a more stable solution. Vuescan vs epson scan software epson software does seem to have a lot of bells and whistles that actually do something, i was testing scanning some magazine images and what gets pulled the tiff looks nothing like whats on the page thats not to say the mags quality is top notch. I risk an angry mob at my door when i say this, but i will move forward anyway. This work is licensed under a creative commons attributionnoncommercialnoderivatives 4. When it comes to image quality, you want the best you can afford.
Just like silverfast, vuescan has colour profiles for a load of different negative films. Between epson scan, silverfast, or vuescan there isnt a difference. Vuescan vs epson scan software cambridge in colour. As far as i know vuescan supports linux just fine so thatd be one less thing to worry about, silverfast 8 doesnt which means id have to run the software on a windows 10 virtual machine, which is not a big deal but i dont know if this would cause any problems when scanning. Peter fuller today, i would like to share something a little different here on scan your entire life. It also comes with lifetime free updates for the professional edition and works on all scanners that you own, not just the one that you purchase it for like silverfast. A potentially important plus for vuescan is that hamrick software says it supports more than 2,000 models, compared with silverfast supporting about 350, so. I see a place for both being honest, though if i had nothingi would pick vuescan anyday over silverfast. Vuescan includes a driver for your scanner even though it isnt support anymore. Vuescan is the easiest way to get your scanner working on macos catalina, windows 10 and more. Linear raw scans with epson v800 and vuescan analog. Silverfast is very comprehensive, but i just prefer vuescan. I have come to the forgone conclusion that the best workflow i have found for scanning was to use the epsonscan software bundled with my v600. Download setup filevuescan 9 crack full version incl patch download vuescan is an application for scanning documents, photos, film, and slides on windows, macos, and linux.
And now that the lightroom plugin negative lab pro has become part of my workflow, vuescan is the only software i can use. It started out as vuesmart, a replacement for the hewlettpackard photosmarts crippled native software. When you use epson scan or silverfast, zooming into an image will force a rescan of the selected image. A similar situation exists with silverfast, another thirdparty scanning application. Vuescan vs silverfast, is one better than the other. Im scanning some color negative, which ive always had a bit of trouble with color and exposure wise. Vuescan gives me much better control over image quality, even if it isnt perfect either. Ive been pretty satisfied with vuescan the last few years.
In the past i have tried vuescan and epson but this version of silverfast puts them to shame. Nikon scan vs vuescan vs silverfast scanning back in 2007, when i first got into digital photography, i decided to get a scanner to scan my old film negatives and also so my dad could scan his large collection of slides. In this video, i go over my film scanning workflow using vuescan software and an epson v500 and then compare the results with epson scan. It appears i can get a discount on an upgrade to silverfast 8. Nikon scan, silverfast or vuescan for coolscan 5000. In this post, ill walk you through the process of obtaining a linear scan using vuescan 9 9. Ed hamrick updates his software almost daily it seems and will address any problems that you have on a.
It supports optical character recognition ocr of text documents the software can be downloaded and used free of charge, but adds a watermark on scans until a license is purchased. Silverfast is licensed per scanner so if you ever get a second scanner, you need a second license of silverfast. Vuescan is one of the most famous film scanning software possibilities. Vuescan vs silverfast seai plus 8 film forum leica forum. The other main issue was that they tried to rip me off a second time when there software became incompatible with the then current ios. Where silverfast scores over vuescan is that its scans exhibit greater contrast, which make them appear. Silverfast and vuescan are the most commonly used professional tools for scanning film and slides.
Only need a single license and it comes with lifetime free updates. It is the only software supporting the heidelberg scanner on mac os x and microsoft windows 2000, xp, vista and 7. The tradeoff here is that the zoomed in image in vuescan has a very small resolution. Silverfast is not bad, its simply just to big a hassle to use. Since the nikon scan software is not supported by the newer generation apple computers, i dont know.
Ive used vuescan since before it was called vuescan. I just read on the lasersoft site that silverfast has better solutions for some of the functions, but somehow i doubt. I have tinkered with vuescan and silverfast quite a bit. There is a definite plus here with using vuescan, as it lets you zoom into the image. Learn more about it and why our silverfast is the worldwide leading software. For the same or better scan quality you can purchase vuescan for a fraction of the cost. I could see the difference in the images that where scanned with epson software vs vuescan. I believe the best software to use all of the functionality the ls5000 offers is still the old nikon scan software. Easier to use, nicer results, and it costs a whole lot less.
A potentially important plus for vuescan is that hamrick software says it supports more than 2,000 models, compared with silverfast. Throwing out silverfast and replacing it with vuescan my. Why i switched silverfast for vuescan david naylor. A few years ago, i purchased the minolta secondhand off ebay for about 350 pounds sterling. Sowohl bei vuescan als auch bei silverfast kannst du diese einstellen. The years progressed and at some point the software failed to work reliably with my computer and so i upgraded to vuescan. A couple months ago, peter fuller, a fellow reader of this website wrote and shared with me his experience getting started on the project of scanning his entire photo. For calibrating your scanner, we recommend our patented and awardwinning auto it8 calibration using a calibration target from our own production in combination with silverfast ai studio 8 or archive suite 8. Usually its just me going on and on about my experience dealing with my photo collection. Again, the real time view of changes in silverfast is a very attractive feature. The unthinkable switching from vuescan to silverfast film forum. Do you think that the silverfast interface is better than vuescan. The vuescan vs silverfast debate settled itself nicely. Same with vuescan, most setting needs a tweak to get the best from them, silverfast is more geared to tweaking in that app, vs is more basic, but you can pp after the scan.
45 1433 1475 54 145 133 514 909 1115 317 216 900 435 1589 646 1014 633 1226 69 873 1370 860 764 381 757 1599 598 921 312 227 687 907 518 881 9